The
Authority Test: Christianity Or Humanism?
Bodie
Hodge, M.Sc., B.Sc., PEI
Biblical
Authority Ministries, September 24, 2025 (Donate)
Part
1: Testing Christians’ Ultimate Authority
Why
The Need For This Test?
There
are many Christians who say they believe in biblical authority. They may even
claim to adhere to biblical inerrancy and say they take the Bible “literally,”
or as it is written. However, in practice, many of these Christians
often ignore the Bible.
The
primary reason many Christians do not adhere to biblical authority in practice
is that they are influenced by the religion of humanism—and may not even
realize it. Humanism is the common religion of the times. As Christians, we
need to be able to effectively recognize and refute it. In this article I will
present the “authority test” to help Christians recognize when humanism is
trying to overstep the authority of God. But before I explain what I mean by
“the authority test,” let’s look at the influence of humanism.
Influence
Of Humanism
In
today’s culture, the religion of humanism has infiltrated the thinking of
Christians, whether laity, pastors, elders, or professors. Humanism is a
religion that essentially places humans on top and everything else below. So,
in this religion, God would be lower than man—or there is really no God at all.
Image from Presentation Library
Humanism
really began taking hold in the western world with the widespread rejection of
God as the authority beginning about 200 or so years ago. Humanism has become
the staple religion in universities and state schools around the world and is
directly opposed to biblical authority.
Some
famous humanists are Dr. Eugenie Scott, who heads up the National Center for
Science Education, and Dr. Richard Dawkins, who openly professes atheism and
writes books that attack Christianity. Both were signers of the Humanist
Manifesto III. However, many people think "humanisticly" (having autonomous man as the
authority), whether they realize there is a Humanist Manifesto or not. With
humanism being the prime religion taught in today’s schools, it is no surprise
that younger generations think as though mankind is the authority.
God
Is The Authority
Contrary
to what the world believes, we know that God, being the Creator and Sustainer
of all things, is the ultimate authority in all things. Consider God’s Word:
All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness, that the man of God may be complete, thoroughly equipped for every good work. I charge you therefore before God and the Lord Jesus Christ, who will judge the living and the dead at His appearing and His kingdom: Preach the word! Be ready in season and out of season. Convince, rebuke, exhort, with all longsuffering and teaching. For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine, but according to their own desires, because they have itching ears, they will heap up for themselves teachers; and they will turn their ears away from the truth, and be turned aside to fables. But you be watchful in all things, endure afflictions, do the work of an evangelist, fulfill your ministry (NKJV). (2 Timothy 3:16–4:5)
Image from Presentation Library
God
determines what is right or wrong. Therefore, His Word, i.e., Scripture, is
useful for rebuking and correcting. Even people, families, and governing
authorities for various cultures can get laws and rules for civil life correct
from time to time, but this is because they are borrowing from what God has
determined as right and wrong.
The
context surrounding 2 Timothy 3:16
reveals that there is a time when people will no longer adhere to sound
doctrine from God but will leave the concepts of right and wrong up to their
own desires. When one raises up his own desires to be the authority, this is
humanism, where humans think they can sit in authority over God. Paul writing
to Timothy here says that this philosophy will influence teachers and turn
people away from the truth to fables. In today’s culture, this is exactly what
is happening with universities and schools and why Christians need to be
exceptionally discerning lest they be led astray to fables by humanism (e.g.,
molecules-to-man evolution) instead of resting on Scripture.
The
Authority Test
Image in original article
1 Thessalonians
5:21–22 (NKJV) says that we must “Test all things; hold fast to that which is good.” God helps us think through the
issues, using the standards of Scripture, to determine what is good and right.
Then we should hold fast to that.
Using
the following authority test can play a big part in the process of thinking
through the issues. The authority test is this: “Does the
idea/statement/presupposition that I am confronted with have man as the
ultimate authority or the God of the Bible as the ultimate authority? Are man’s
thoughts exalted above God’s Word, or is the Word of God honored?”
This
authority test can be used two ways:
1. To better
yourself by realizing where humanism has infiltrated your life and accordingly
changing to align with God’s Word (2 Corinthians
13:5)
2. To recognize
when others are thinking “humanisticly” and being able to reveal that fallacy
to prepare to refute it (2 Corinthians
10:3–6)
Brief
Examples In Scripture
There
are quite a number of examples in Scripture where God’s authority was reduced
and man’s ideas were raised up to be greater than what God said. Here are a few
of the many biblical examples that illustrate this:
1. Adam and Eve,
Genesis 3: When the Woman
(later named Eve in verse 20) was presented with two different options (what
God said and what the serpent said), she raised her thoughts up to be the
authority on the subject. The Woman saw the fruit and desired it. She raised
her own thoughts of the fruit above what God said about the fruit in Genesis 2:17, which she
was more or less aware of (Genesis 3:2–3).
She, thus, was first to exhibit this humanist trait. Then Adam followed suit.
2. Cain, Genesis 4:1–12:
Cain’s sacrifice didn’t mimic sacrifices of animals as God did in Genesis 3:21 for Adam and
Eve (coats of skins). His sacrifice for this or other reasons was not
acceptable compared to Abel’s, who did have animal sacrifices. God advised
Cain, yet Cain did not listen to God, and, in his anger over God’s authority to
determine what is and what is not acceptable, went out and killed his brother
Abel. This violates God’s transcendent law against murder. So, Cain raised up
his own thoughts to be greater than God’s by rejecting them. Once again,
humanist thinking.
3. Saul, 1 Samuel 15: Instead of
listening to God, Saul decided to keep back what he considered the best animal
plunder to supposedly sacrifice to God, as opposed to destroying them as the
Lord had commanded. Saul opted to have his own thoughts on the matter to be
greater than God.
4. Pharisees, Matthew 12:38: The
Pharisees wanted to see a sign from Jesus. They placed themselves in authority
by trying to force Jesus, the almighty God, to submit to their wishes to prove
Himself to them, thus putting themselves in authority over God.
Putting
Ideas And Comments To The Test In Today’s Culture
Christians
should learn from these types of examples, because once one reduces God as the
authority, then man’s ideas, by default, become the authority. Sadly, many
Christians fail to realize that when this happens, the authority is transferred
over to man’s erroneous ideas and philosophies and no longer comes from Christ
for some. Consider:
Beware lest anyone cheat you through philosophy and empty deceit, according to the tradition of men, according to the basic principles of the world, and not according to Christ. (Colossians 2:8, NKJV)
As
Christians, we need to be able to discern if the ideas of men (even our own)
are sitting in a position of authority over God’s Word. Here are three
examples:
1. Cults: Many
cults claim to add to the Word of God. In reality, they are raising up man’s
words to be equal to or greater than God’s Word. This is a form of humanism. As
soon as one refers to a book, magazine, organization, etc. as having equal or
greater authority than the Bible, then that should be a red flag to anyone that
humanism has infiltrated.
2. The deity of
Christ: John 1, Colossians 1, and Hebrews 1 are clear that
Jesus Christ is the Creator God. Some people demean this and reduce the deity
of Christ. This is man sitting in authority over God’s Word—again. For more on
this see Is Jesus the
Creator God?
3. Millions of
years: In no place in Scripture is the idea that the earth is millions of years
old. Adding up genealogies will not get anyone even close to millions of years.
The idea of millions and billions of years comes from fallible man’s ideas
about the past. These fallible men interpret the geological rock layers as accumulating over millions of years, and hence, these men
reject God’s Word in Genesis 6–8
about a global Flood.
If one accepts these ideas, knowing that these ideas contradict God’s Word,
then they are putting man’s ideas over God’s ideas. Isn’t it clear how
humanistic this really is? Unfortunately, even sincere Christians can begin to
adjust their methods of interpretation so that their interpretation of the
Bible becomes consistent with the secular “findings” of science. These
Christians may not be willfully setting up their ideas over God’s Word, but
they are being heavily influenced by the results of humanistic thinking. There
is no legitimate reason to reject a plain reading of the Genesis record of
creation and the Flood. It is when Christians examine the “evidence” of secular
geology in light of God’s Word, rather than the other way around, that they
will be able to understand that the evolutionary timeline is in error. The
antidote for the influence of humanistic thinking is to view Scripture as
authoritative.
Consider
these comments and try to spot the humanism in these:
a. My pastor
said that our particular church agrees that evolution and the Bible are
compatible.
b. The Bible
doesn’t mean a normal day in Genesis 1 because science says it is much longer.
With
[a], the writer of this statement appeals to the pastor, who appeals to the
specific local church, which appeals to man’s ideas about millions of years and
evolution. There can be multiple levels to search through before you spot the
humanism at the root.
With
[b], again the person appeals to “science,” but really they mean a secular
interpretation of scientific facts.
We
must use our God-given mind to reach logical conclusions, but if our minds
interpret facts in such a way that our conclusion contradicts God’s Word, then
we must reject that conclusion and give God the benefit of the doubt.
Otherwise, we are guilty of humanistic thinking. We must allow God’s Word to be
the ultimate authority.
My
prayer is that each one of us will use the authority test on a daily basis to
correct our thinking. This is one of the first steps to get back to biblical
authority.
It
is important to realize that when man tries to sit in authority over the Word
of God, then man is trying to judge God. But God makes it clear that it is He
and His Word that will judge us.
Part
2: Testing Humanism And Witnessing
Once
Christians begin to get themselves back to biblical authority, then the next
challenge is humanism in the culture. Consider these comments that are common
in today’s society and try to spot the humanism in these:
1. The paper
from the latest scientific journal says dinosaurs and man didn’t live at the
same time.
2. Most
scientists believe in evolution, so it must be true.
3. The Bible
can’t be true because it is full of contradictions.
In
[a], the paper from the journal is given authority over the Bible’s statement
that on Day 6, God created both man and land animals (dinosaurs). Where did the
paper come from? Fallible man.
In
[b], it appeals to multiple humans (scientists) as an authority over God and
implies consensus is the method by which we determine truth—but how often has
that consensus changed? The consensus in Noah’s day was that there would be no
Flood!
In
[c], the person is sitting in authority over God’s Word claiming there are
contradictions (which there aren’t), and, in effect, that God is lying or can’t
get His facts straight in what He claims is His Word, true, perfect and
complete (Revelation 22:18,
19; 2 Timothy 3:15,16; 2 Timothy 2:15; Romans 3:2; Romans 2:16; Hebrews 4:12, etc.).
Following
Up The Test In Practice
The
authority test simply allows you to recognize the root of a belief
system—either going back to God or going back to humanity. But what is the next
step? The goals are threefold:
1. To reveal to
that person the real religion that they believe or have been influenced by is
humanism
2. To show the
foundational problems with that view
3. To present
what the Bible says and culminate with the gospel
Many
people who think humanisticly simply don’t realize it. So, the first
goal is to reveal this to them. Perhaps challenge a humanistic worldview (in
kindness) by asking questions about how they view the world and how their
beliefs relate to things in reality. This is usually a non-threatening way to
get people to think about their beliefs (Christian or not) more deeply because
they probably haven’t—especially the foundation for their belief system.
This
also reveals problems with the foundation of humanism. For example, ask that
person why people wear clothes in general. The person may be a bit taken aback,
but what this shows is that a humanistic view of the past really doesn’t
explain the world. Ultimately, of course, clothing is a Christian aspect that
goes back to sin, shame, and sacrifice in Genesis 3.
Or
ask about marriage—where does the idea of marriage come from? (Ultimately, it
comes from the Bible, too). Ask why death exists and if “right and wrong” exist
and what is the ultimate standard by which we judge what is right or wrong. Ask
if truth exists; if so, what exactly is it? And then ask if truth is the same
for everyone. Ask where the world and universe came from; and where the stars
came from; and where life came from; and so on.
A
few questions like these should get the person thinking—without being
“preachy.” What will likely happen, though, is that a person will reveal what
they really believe about origins . . . which is probably a mixture of some big
bang, long ages, and evolution with some spirituality—or even some
Christianity—mixed in.
When
some of that comes out, point out the areas in which they are thinking as a
humanist (evolution, naturalism, long ages, big bang, etc. are subsets of
humanism). You may even have to explain it. Once they realize how humanism has
influenced them, then proceed to point out that humans (or even that person
individually) are really raising themselves up to be “a god” by placing
themselves as the ultimate authority. Point out that humanism is really a
polytheistic religion where each human is his own “god.”
Image from Presentation Library
This
should get through any humanist thinking, but then suggest to them that the
Bible does explain things like the origin of matter, space, time, stars,
marriage, clothing, truth, and so on. Then go into the doctrine of sin and that
a perfect God originally created everything perfect. It was due to man’s sin
that the world is like this—full of death and suffering. Then this can lead
into the gospel, and how Christ came to save us from sin and death.
While
witnessing, remember to be kind and patient (1 Peter 3:15; 2 Timothy 2:24). After
all, we were each enemies of the gospel ourselves at one point (Colossians 1:21)—but Jesus
Christ was patient with us and performed the ultimate act of kindness on the
cross.
□
Bodie
Hodge, Ken Ham's son in law, has been an apologist since 1998 helping out in
various churches and running an apologetics website. He spent 21 years working
at Answers in Genesis as a speaker, writer, and researcher as
well as a founding news anchor for Answers News. He was also head
of the Oversight Council.
Bodie
launched Biblical Authority Ministries in 2015 as a personal
website and it was organized officially in 2025 as a 501(c)(3). He has spoken
on multiple continents and hosts of US states in churches, colleges, and
universities. He is married with four children.
Originally
at Answers in Genesis; Edited; Republished by permission.